I would like to know the best way to tag a point that shows the error in zone temperature compared to the zone's effective setpoint, I have come up with this list:
point
zone
air
temp
deviation
sensor
kind: "Number"
unit: "°F"
I have been having some debate in substituting the following with:
Substitube deviation with delta
Substitute unit: "°F" with unit: "Δ°F"
What are everyone's thoughts?
Paul QuinnThu 15 Feb 2018
The "delta" tag is the stndard Haystack tag to indicate a difference between points. Using a tag instead of an engineering unit makes it queryable in Axon and other functions.
Alex BibleThu 15 Feb 2018
By convention "delta" is the difference between two sensors, offering a change value across two different inputs.
I suppose from a design standpoint, my question would be what do you mean by "error in zone temperature"? Does this mean you have a setpoint, and this is the +/- deviation from that setpoint? If so, does this really need to be a point rather than a calculated value?
Christian TremblayThu 15 Feb 2018
My 2 cents would be that this point would not need to be tagged.... as you already tagged setpoint and temperature... the haystack server should be able to tell you what's the difference between the two. It's a calculated value.
Brian FrankThu 22 Feb 2018
Existing convention is that delta is difference between two different sensors.
This sounds more like the delta between sp and sensor for the same logical measurement (zone temp). It feels like the term delta for that situation is not semantically the same with previous usage.
So I would vote for something more like deviation (or maybe spDeviation)
Chad Ruch Mon 12 Feb 2018
I would like to know the best way to tag a point that shows the error in zone temperature compared to the zone's effective setpoint, I have come up with this list:
point
zone
air
temp
deviation
sensor
kind: "Number"
unit: "°F"
I have been having some debate in substituting the following with:
deviation
withdelta
unit: "°F"
withunit: "Δ°F"
What are everyone's thoughts?
Paul Quinn Thu 15 Feb 2018
The "delta" tag is the stndard Haystack tag to indicate a difference between points. Using a tag instead of an engineering unit makes it queryable in Axon and other functions.
Alex Bible Thu 15 Feb 2018
By convention "delta" is the difference between two sensors, offering a change value across two different inputs.
I suppose from a design standpoint, my question would be what do you mean by "error in zone temperature"? Does this mean you have a setpoint, and this is the +/- deviation from that setpoint? If so, does this really need to be a point rather than a calculated value?
Christian Tremblay Thu 15 Feb 2018
My 2 cents would be that this point would not need to be tagged.... as you already tagged setpoint and temperature... the haystack server should be able to tell you what's the difference between the two. It's a calculated value.
Brian Frank Thu 22 Feb 2018
Existing convention is that
delta
is difference between two different sensors.This sounds more like the delta between
sp
andsensor
for the same logical measurement (zone temp). It feels like the term delta for that situation is not semantically the same with previous usage.So I would vote for something more like deviation (or maybe spDeviation)