I've been struggling with tagging IDEC (Indirect Direct Evaporative Cooling) systems. I don't tag them as evaporators because that's for refrigerant systems. I want to use coolingProcess but the existing choice items can't be used for evaporative cooling process. Does it make sense to add evaporativeCooling as a coolingProcess choice? I want to know other users' opinions on this and how they are tagging (non-refrigerant) evaporative cooling equipment in general.
Paul QuinnWed 11 Dec
I have clients with large air handlers that have both direct and indirect evaporative cooling. I use the tags evapDirect and evapIndirect to distinguish between equipment and points on the two systems.
Sade OdumuyeWed 11 Dec
We use a custom evapCooling tag at the AHU equip level for direct evap cooling, and agree that this should be included as a coolingProcess choice.
We also add a marker tag evap to standard point, sets such as pump commands or air temps (analogous to chillled for CHW cooling equipment).
Hiroko MasudaTue 17 Dec
Thank you for your replies, Paul and Sade. For now, we are going to use evapCooling and evap. Direct or indirect can be subtypes of evapCooling, but we'll ignore that difference to move on for now.
Hiroko Masuda Tue 10 Dec
I've been struggling with tagging IDEC (Indirect Direct Evaporative Cooling) systems. I don't tag them as evaporators because that's for refrigerant systems. I want to use
coolingProcess
but the existing choice items can't be used for evaporative cooling process. Does it make sense to add evaporativeCooling as a coolingProcess choice? I want to know other users' opinions on this and how they are tagging (non-refrigerant) evaporative cooling equipment in general.Paul Quinn Wed 11 Dec
I have clients with large air handlers that have both direct and indirect evaporative cooling. I use the tags evapDirect and evapIndirect to distinguish between equipment and points on the two systems.
Sade Odumuye Wed 11 Dec
We use a custom
evapCooling
tag at the AHU equip level for direct evap cooling, and agree that this should be included as a coolingProcess choice.We also add a marker tag
evap
to standard point, sets such as pump commands or air temps (analogous tochillled
for CHW cooling equipment).Hiroko Masuda Tue 17 Dec
Thank you for your replies, Paul and Sade. For now, we are going to use evapCooling and evap. Direct or indirect can be subtypes of evapCooling, but we'll ignore that difference to move on for now.